Introduction
Isabel Coixet directed the 2019 Spanish historical romantic drama Elisa & Marcela. It tells the true story of Galician women Elisa Sánchez Loriga and Marcela Gracia Ibeas who, in 1901, planned one of the earliest same-sex marriages in Spain. For years, their story was forgotten until it was uncovered in historical documents and adapted for the screen. The film, shot in black and white and released on Netflix, is remarkable for both its love story and its act of historical reclamation.
Although the cinematography and setting of the film are black-and-white and reminiscent of classical European cinema, the core emotions portraying defiance, passion, and sacrifice are timeless and urgent. Marcela and Elisa’s love story, the first recorded same-sex marriage in Spain, represents love in the face of oppression. The story continues to hold relevance to contemporary discussions around LGBTQ+ rights and visibility.
Note: The text is analysis/summary of the novel Elisa and Marcela.
With the world already modernized, Spain in the late 1890s simply comes as the setting for the novel. Elisa & Marcela starts off with both the women meeting for the first time as they are teenagers at a convent school in Galicia, only to spark major conflict later on in the story. Elisa was energetic and confident, while Marcela was a lot more introverted. Marcela took cautiousness to another level, where it became self-defense as a result of the romance found in the setting combining deep friendships. Resistance and Therapy, two socially knitted words formed through the lense of a conservative setting, drove the women apart. This isoltered a further deep exploration of their romance out of pure avoidance.
Things only became a whole lot more intense and deep the older they became. In an attempt to save Marcela’s reputation, Elisa leaves the school. Loose ends were gradually generated along the way. Both women came back together after many years apart from one another. They both came back as well-educated school teachers situated in different nearby towns. In the midst of it, their love turned into a still passionate and persistent detail of their lives, despite the secrecy surrounding it.
With people being more extra and watchful as time passed, it finally took a turn to be nosy. Family and parish priest joined the mix, taking over the couple’s personal space to question their lives. On her part, the couple decided to take the major radical step to “socially switch genders” The. Reserving the relationship and openly targeting fellow peers drove the under Elisa male scheme calling herself “Mario Sanchez” concept further in society. The two were finally able to disguised disguised get married and even keep their ceremony at A coruña wholly in the year 1901. The marriage was able to blend all together and legally registered without the sneaky disguised piecing details exposed through their very unaware traditional civil authorities.
Yet, they do not manage to keep their secret hidden for long. Once the couple’s ruse is uncovered, they are pursued by the police, demonized by the media, and ultimately forced to flee to Portugal. Here, they undergo incarceration and are kept apart. Through all this, they never give up on loving each other. The film finishes with a poignant scene, reminding the audience that although their union was legally nullified, the couple’s courageous act was – and still is – a beacon of hope for posterity.
Historical Context
What is elisa & marcela’s defining characteristic is not only the tale itself, but its importance highlights and its social significance. In 1901, Spain was a deeply conservative country, still heavily influenced by the Catholic Church and the patriarchy. The very thought of two women picking out a wedding dress and saying “I do” to each other, not to mention marrying under the guise of patriarchal societal norms was utterly absurd.
Their marriage certificate was, and still is, regarded by historians as one of the earliest same-sex marriages in Europe. In spite of their eventual forced relocation and the public erasure of their romance, their story stands as a testament against the social orthodoxy of the time.
Character and Portrayals
Marcela is brought to life by Natalia de Molina, who captures fierce devotion as well as raw vulnerability. She gives voice, vividly, to the two extremes battling to capture her heart, love, and longing for freedom grappling with societal expectations.
Elisa is portrayed by Greta Fernández, who exhibits remarkable prowess, skill, and presence. It is haunting and tragic at the same time when a woman risks everything, including her identity, for love.
They both, together and individually, create the film’s emotional bedrock with their undeniable chemistry. They approach their romantic relationship with realism that balances tenderness and sensuality so the viewers cannot help but root for them.
Camera work and the cut
The story inspires the viewer to root for the main character: Isabel Coixet, in my opinion, made creatively poignant choices, such as recording the movie in black and white, which to me was particularly striking. With this approach, she manages to blend raw emotional subtleties with timelessness and historical weight, filtering through the film’s visual elements. Every scene in grayscale strips the deep, romantic core of emotion contained in each glance, stroke, or soft-silent dialogue, rendering it ever so intimate and pure.
The shoots by Jennifer Cox feature love and repression using natural soft lights and poetic framing. From the tranquil countryside to the domineering church interiors, the camera captures the immense social scrutiny surrounding the couple at every nook and cranny.
Coixet’s direction steers clear of over-sentimentalizing the film. Rather, she approaches it with gentle cruelty, allowing true and raw love between Elisa and Marcela to flow naturally.
Themes and Symbolism
Elisa & Marcela encompasses a myriad of themes such as love, identity, defiance, and the ever-enduring human spirit. One of the film’s central themes is freedom and the pricing that comes with it. The couple’s decision to live authentically costs them a lot—a high social ostracization, exile, and imprisonment—but is worth it for love.
Another primary theme is the performative character of gender. The society’s norm is based on surface parameters, which makes Elisa’s makeover into Mario all the more important. Their marriage being possible just because Elisa passing for a man underscores the arbitrary rules of gender placed by legal and ecclesiastical frameworks.
The movie also critiques, even if only implicitly, the church and other established institutions for trespassing into an individual’s life. The couple is married in a Catholic Church, but the Church later excommunicates them, which illustrates the hypocrisy of an institution that professes to bring love and yet relentlessly continues to inflict violence.
Reception and Legacy
Most critics gave Elisa & Marcela mixed to positive reviews. Some appreciated emotional depth and its historical relevance, while others criticized the plot as being too subdued and the pacing too slow. Regardless, the film was lauded for its attempt to retell a forgotten story and bring it onto the international stage.
Elisa & Marcela was the first original Spanish movie produced by Netflix, which marked a new milestone in film distribution as the movie was made available digitally to audiences around the world. It also added to the conversation around representation, LGBTQ+ issues, and history in cinema.
Conclusion
Elisa y Marcela is a film with captivating sequences that portray a deeply emotional vibrant tale of love. The film recovers a lost history and transforms it into a moving chronicle of bravery and undying love through masterfully executed performances, evocative movies, and delicate manipulation. While it does not cater to the tastes of the average viewer, it succeeds as a compelling work of art that reminds us—of the many things love binds, it must always be cherished, regardless of the form it takes.
Watch free movies on Fmovies